Search
As earnings season approaches, investors brace for critical updates that can send stocks soaring or tumbling. While consensus estimates dominate headlines, there exists a quieter, more potent forecast known as the earnings whisper. These informal, often unpublished forecasts shed light on the market’s true earnings expectation, guiding savvy traders toward better-informed decisions.
Unlike the consensus estimate—an average of published forecasts—an earnings whisper represents the analysts’ true earnings expectations. These whisper numbers were once shared privately among select clients or traders, born from off‐the‐record conversations and insider insights.
Today, services like Earnings Whispers aggregate these numbers, making them accessible to a wider audience. Investors who monitor whispers gain an edge by aligning their expectations with those analysts who have the most direct information on company performance.
Early academic research by Bagnoli, Beneish, and Watts in the Journal of Accounting & Economics found that whispers derive from private information or market rumors and proved to be statistically more accurate and valuable than consensus estimates. Initially elusive, whisper numbers have become systematically collected and published, thanks to the digitization of analyst models and direct contacts with forecasting professionals.
Over 25 years, more than 117,000 Earnings Whisper® numbers have been published, reflecting a wealth of data that has elevated whisper numbers from rumor to respected forecasting tool.
Empirical evidence underscores the impact of whisper numbers on stock prices. As of June 2023, the Earnings Whisper® number was closer to actual reported earnings 70% of the time, outperforming consensus estimates in predictive power.
These reactions highlight that beating consensus alone provides no statistical benefit; it is the whisper number that truly moves markets.
The Post-Earnings Announcement Drift describes the tendency of stock prices to continue drifting in the direction of the earnings surprise for up to 91 days after the announcement. First documented in 1968 by Ball & Brown, PEAD remains robust across market cycles, driven by delayed information assimilation and behavioral biases.
Investors leveraging PEAD can capture sustained returns by trading on surprise signals generated against whisper expectations rather than consensus figures.
To quantify the predictive power of whispers, the Earnings Whisper Grade evaluates the likelihood of price drift in the quarter following an earnings release. This grade blends earnings results with investor sentiment to forecast trajectory.
Backtesting and real-time results since 2015 confirm the grade’s reliability as a guide for post-earnings strategies.
Richard Bernstein’s Life Cycle framework integrates fundamentals and sentiment into four phases, each defined by the company’s position relative to whisper expectations.
By mapping a stock’s whisper grade to its life cycle phase, investors can anticipate shifts in sentiment and potential price trajectories.
Integrating whisper numbers and the Whisper Grade into your process can enhance both entry and exit timing. Consider these steps:
Caveats include the potential for abrupt guidance changes and the influence of broader market volatility, underscoring the need for risk management.
Ultimately, whispers offer a deeper view of market sentiment than published estimates alone, empowering investors to react proactively rather than lag behind headline-driven moves.
In an era of ever-expanding data, earnings whispers remind us that informal forecasts can rival formal research. As whisper numbers gain prominence, their integration into quantitative and fundamental strategies reshapes how investors interpret earnings season.
By decoding analyst whispers, you equip yourself with an invaluable tool—one that can transform earnings announcements from uncertain gambles into informed opportunities in the quest for portfolio outperformance.
